PROBLEM ON APPLICATION OF “BUSINESS INTERFERENCE” UNDER TRADE COMPETITION ACT 1999

Main Article Content

Nonthaporn Rambuth

Abstract

Competition laws across the world have the same mission – to promote free and fair competition in economic environments and control anti-competitive practices.  Business interference is one of many conducts prohibited by Torts Law and Competition Law.  Under Thai Competition Law, unreasonable or improper interference by dominance position is prohibited by the Trade Competition Act 1999 Section 25 (4).  However, confusion on application of business interference under the Trade Competition Act is a huge problem and caused by the law not being as efficient as it should be.  This article aims to study the application of business interference conduct under the Competition Law and its historical development, and related theories of provisions of treaties, laws, and regulations of the United State Antitrust Law, the European Union Competition Law, and Thailand Competition Law to propose appropriate measures to achieve legislations intent on business interference provision under the Trade Competition Act 1999. 


This article focuses mainly on the study of the measures and existing legislations in the United States and the European Union regarding control and protection of market efficiency from business interference. These will then be compared to find appropriate solutions for the improvement of Section 25(4) of the Trade Competition Act 1999 of Thailand.


The current legal provisions of the United States and the European Union on application of business interference under the Competition Law illustrate confusion in the application of business interference under the Trade Competition Act 1999, deeming it inefficient. This can be solved by amending the law by empowering and giving responsibility to the Trade Competition Commission in order to announce a guideline for Section 25, which consists of elements to allege business interference. 

Article Details

Section
Articles

References

Gifford, Daniel J. and Raskind, Leo J. American casebook series: Federal Antitrust Law cases and materials. United States: West Publishing Company, 1983.

Rodger, Barry J. and MacCulloch, Angus. Competition Law and Policy in the EC and UK. 4th ed. United Kingdom: Routledge-Cavendish, 2009.

ธนิตกุล, ศักดา. คำอธิบายและกรณีศึกษาพระราชบัญญัติการแข่งขันทางการค้า พ.ศ.2542. พิมพ์ครั้งที่ 2. กรุงเทพฯ: สำนักพิมพ์วิญญูชน, 2553. (Thanitcul, Sakda. Explication and case study of Trade Competition Act 1999. 2nd ed. Bangkok: Winyuchon, 2553.)

Anthony, David N. “Tortious Interference with Contract or Business Expectancy: An Overview of Virginia Law.” The Virginia Bar Association News Journal(October-November 2006).

Creed, Jesse Max. “Integrating Preliminary Agreements into the Interference Torts.”Columbia Law review, Volume. 110:1253 (2010).

Hawk, Barry E. and Laudati, Laraine L. “Antitrust Federalism in the United Statesand Decentralization of Competition Law Enforcement in the EuropeanUnion: A Comparison.” Fordham International Law Journal, Volume. 20, Issue 1, Article 2 (1996).

Kumar, Raj. “Structure – Conduct – Performance Paradigm.” Industrial Economic, Delhi University.

McCann, Kevin and Katz, Alyse L. “When Business Torts Give Rise to Antitrust Liability.” American Bar Association (October 17, 2011).

Myers, Gary. “The Differing Treatment of efficiency and competition in Antitrust Law.” Minnesota Law Review, Volume 77:1097 (1993).

Newman, Zachary G. and Ellis, Anthony P. “Navigating the Nuances of Tortious Interference Claims.” Business Torts Journal American Bar Association Section of Litigation, Volume 18 (November 4, 2011).

Nikomborirak, Duenden. “Building Constituency in Competition Policy: Thailand Competition Law & Policy.” Thailand Development Research Institute (August 2002).

Stanley, Richard C. and Darce, Noel J. “Antitrust Law.” Loyola Law Review, (1989).

Strucke, Maurice E. “American Bar Association Section of Antitrust Law.” Business Torts and Unfair Competition Handbook, 3rd ed. (2014).

Thanitcul, Sakda. “Competition Law in Thailand: A prelimary Anlysis.” Washington University Global Studies law Review, Volume 1 (2002).

จันทรโอภากร, อนันต์. “ความรู้พื้นฐานเกี่ยวกับกฎหมายการแข่งขันการค้า.” วารสารนิติศาสตร์ ปีที่ 29, ฉบับที่ 3, (กันยายน 2542).(Chantara-Opakorn, Anan. “Basic knowledge on Competition Law.” Law Journal, 29, Volume 3 (September 2542).

European Union. EU treaties. http://europa.eu/eu-law/decision- making/treaties/index_en.htm.