Governing Medical Tourism: The Roles of Singaporean Government
Keywords:Medical Tourism, Healthcare, Political Economy, Political Institutions, Thailand
This article seeks to shed light on a question: “What explains a nation’s medical tourism?” This paper focuses on the roles played by a central government in shaping the industry, espescially how it balances the advantages and disadvantages of pursuing medical tourism, which has been under-examined. I attempt to fill such intellectual gap by investigating the roles in the Singaporean government in affecting the country's medical tourism. Via this case, I demonstrate how the state’s authorities crafted the rules and regulations to promote the sector and simultaneously cope with the adverse effects that the industry brings to the nation. Insights from my analysis not only extends the existing literatures on the development of medical tourism and roles of domestic political institutions in shaping states’ policy outcomes, but also provides practitioners with lessons useful for crafting effective policies to sustain their countries’ pursuit of medical tourism.
Baker, J.A. (2018MOH publishes fee benchmarks for surgical procedures in private hospitals. Channel News Asia. Retrieved from https://www.cannel newsasia.com/news/health/moh-publishes-medical-fee-benchmarks-private-hospital-10926294
Barr, M. (2008). Singapore: The limits of a technocratic approach to health care. Journal of Contemporary Asia, 38(3), 395-416.
Beladi, H., Chao, C., Ee, M., & Hollas, D. (2015). Medical tourism and health worker migration in developing countries. Economic Modelling, 46(C), 391–396.
Bergstrand, J. (2008). Operating Profit. Economist. Retrieved from https://www.economist.com/briefing/2008/08/14/operating-profit
Bookman, M. Z., & Bookman, K. R. (2007). Medical Tourism in Developing Countries, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Central Provident Fund. (2018). Medisave. Retrieved from https://www. cpf.gov.sg/Members/Schemes/schemes/healthcare/medisave
Central Provident Fund Board. (2018, October 29). CFP Contribution and Allocation Rates. Retrieved from https://www.cpf.gov.sg/Employers/EmployerGuides /employer-guides/paying-cpf-contributions/cpf-contribution-and-allocation-rates#Item587
Chanda, R. (2002). Trade in Health Services, Bulletin of the World Health Organization 80 (2), 158-163.
Choo, F. (2018). Opting for private surgeon? See fee guidelines. Strait Times. Retrieved from https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/opting-for-private-surgeon -see-fee-guidelines.
Economist Intelligence Unit. (2014). Singapore: A regional medical-tourism hub. The Economist. Retrieved from https://country.eiu.com/article.aspx?articleid =1992338383&Country=Singapore&topic=Economy
Elis (2017). Important Information Before Applying a License. Ministry of Health Singapore. Retrieved from https://elis.moh.gov.sg/elis/info.do?task= guidelines§ion=GuideGeneralInfo
Channel News Asia. (2016). MOH welcomes taskforce's proposals to keep health insurance costs down. Retrieved from https://www.channelnewsasia.com /news/singapore/moh-welcomes-taskforce-s-proposals-to-keep-health-insurance-cost-7763226
Chen, Y. B., & Flood, C. M. (2013). Medical tourism's impact on health care equity and access in low-and middle-income countries: making the case for regulation. The Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 41(1), 286-300.
Cheng, K. (2018). First tranche of medical fee benchmarks slated for release in second half of 2018. TODAY.
Costhelper. (2019). Heart Surgery Cost. Retrieved from https://health. costhelper.com/heart-surgery.html
DBS Group Research. (2017). Singapore Company Guide: Raffles Medical. https://www.dbs.com.sg/treasures//aics/pdfController.page?pdfpath=/content/article/pdf/RFMD_SP_EQUITY/2017/02/RFMD_SP_EQUITY_57_21022017.pdf
Doner, R. (2012). Politics, Institutions and Performance: Explaining Growth Variation in East Asia, ed. by Robinson, R. in Routledge Handbook of Southeast Asian Politics, 151-74. Oxford, U.K.: Routledge.
Doner, R.F., Ritchie, B.K. & Slater, D. (2005). Systemic vulnerability and the origins of developmental: Northeast and Southeast Asia in comparative perspective. International Organization, 59(2), 327-361.
Economic Development Board (2018). Research Incentive Scheme for Companies. Ministry of Trade and Industry, Singapore. Retrieved from https://www.edb.gov.sg/content/dam/edbsite/downloads/brochures/RISC%20Brochure.pdf
Economic Development Board. (2019a). About EDB. Retrieved from https://www.edb.gov.sg/en/about-edb/who-we-are.html
Economic Development Board. (2019b, April 18). Pioneer Certificate Incentive and Development and Expansion Incentive. Retrieved from https: //www.edb.gov.sg/content/dam/edbsite/downloads/brochures/PC%20and%20DEI%20Brochure.PDF
Elis (2018). Important Information Before Applying a License. Ministry of Health Singapore. Retrieved from https://elis.moh.gov.sg/elis/info.do?task=guidelines §ion=GuideGeneralInfo
Enterprise Singapore (2018a). Boost Capabilities Retrieved from https://spring.enterprisesg.gov.sg/Developing-Industries/BHS/Pages/Boost-Capabilities.aspx
Enterprise Singapore (2018b). Double Tax Deduction for Internationalisation. Retrieved from https://www.enterprisesg.gov.sg/financial -assistance /tax-incentives/tax-incentives/Double-Tax-Deduction-for-Internationalisation
Enterprise Singapore (2018c). Internationalisation Finance Scheme (IFS). Retrieved fromhttps://www.enterprisesg.gov.sg/financial-assistance/loans-and-insurance/ loans-and-insurance/internationalisation-finance-scheme
Enterprise Singapore (2019), About enterprise Singapore. Retrieved from https://www.enterprisesg.gov.sg/about-us/overview
Fee Benchmarks Advisory Committee. (2018). Fee Benchmarks Advisory Committee Report. The Ministry of Public Health. Retrieved from https://www.moh.gov.sg/docs/librariesprovider5/pressroom/press-releases/fee-
Foreign Policy. (2008). The Top 5 Countries for Medical Travel. 13 August
Gan, L. (2010, February 20). Usage of CPF Medisave in Malaysia Hospitals and Medical Centers. Ezine article. Retrieved from https://ezinearticles. com/?Usage-of-CPF-Medisave-in-Malaysia-Hospitals-and-Medical-Centers&id=3796780
Gan, L. & Frederick, J. (2011). Medical Tourism in Singapore: Structure-Conduct-Performance Analysis. Journal of Asia-Pacific Business, 12(2), 141-170.
Ganguli, S., & Ebrahim, A. H. (2017). A qualitative analysis of Singapore's medical tourism competitiveness. Tourism Management Perspectives, 21, 74-84.
Grabowski, R. (2012). The Politics of Rapid Growth. Asian-Pacific Economic Literature, 26, 29-40.
Grosse, S. (2016, October 25). MOH to review healthcare regulations amid changing landscape. Channel News Asia. Retrieved from https://www.channel newsasia.com/news/singapore/moh-to-review-healthcare-regulations-amid-changing-landscape-7776796
Haseltine, W. A. (2013). Affordable Excellence: The Singapore Healthcare Story: How to Create and Manage Sustainable Healthcare Systems, Washington D.C.: Brookings Institution Press.
Huang, C. (2016, September 13). Thomson Medical eyes S’pore listing in near term. . Retrieved from https://www.shareinvestor.com/news/news.html?source=sg _stbt&nid=63385
Health Insurance Task Force. (HITF) (2016). Managing the Cost of Health Insurance in Singapore. Life Insurance Association, Singapore. Retrieved from https://www.lia.org.sg/media/1521/managingsingaporehealthinsurancecost_hitf_20161013.pdf
IHH Healthcare Berhad (2018). Healthcare across the Globe. Retrieved from https://www.ihhhealthcare.com/about-global.html
Immigration & Checkpoints Authority Singapore (ICA). (2018a). Check if you need a visa entry. Retrieved from https://www.ica.gov.sg/ visitor/visitor_entryvisa
Immigration & Checkpoints Authority Singapore (ICA). (2018b, November 3). Extension of Short Term Visit Pass (e-XTEND). Retrieved from https://extend.ica.gov.sg/extend/xhtml/StaticPages/eXTEND_PCountry.xhtml
Immigration & Checkpoints Authority (ICA). (2018c, October 30). Extension of Short Term Visit Pass (e-XTEND): Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs). Government of Singapore. Retrieved from https://extend.ica.gov.sg/extend/xhtml /StaticPages/Faq.xhtml#3
Immigration & Checkpoints Authority Singapore (ICA). (2018d). Extension of Short Term Visit Pass (e-XTEND): List of Countries. Retrieved from https://extend.ica.gov.sg/extend/xhtml/StaticPages/eXTEND_PCountry.xhtml
Immigration & Checkpoints Authority Singapore (ICA). (2018e). To Seek Medical Treatment. Retrieved from https://www.ica.gov.sg/visitor/extendyourstay /visitor_extendyourstay_extensionofmedical
International Medical Tourism Journal (IMTJ). (2013). Singapore’s Medical Tourism is Recovering. Retrieved from https://www.imtj.com/news/singapore-medical -tourism-recovering/
Janjaroen, W. S., & S. Supakankunti. (2002). International trade in health services in the millennium: The case of Thailand, eds. by Drager, N. and Vieira, C. in Trade in Health Services: Global, Regional, and Country Perspectives. Washington, D.C.: Pan American Health Organization.
Joint Commission International (JCI). (2018). JCI-Accredited Organizations. Retrieved from https://www.jointcommissioninternational.org/about-jci/jci-accredited -organizations/?c=Singapore
Kangas, B. (2007). Hope from abroad in the international medical travel of Yemeni patients. Anthropology and Medicine, 14(3), 293–305.
Khalik, S. (2015a). Number of foreign doctors rising in Singapore public hospitals and polyclinics. Strait Times. Retrieved from https://www.Straitstimes.com/ singapore/health/number-of-foreign-doctors-rising-in-singapore-public-hospitals-and-polyclinics
Khalik, S. (2015b). Why It Matters: The benefits of community hospitals. Strait Times. Retrieved from https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/the-benefits -of-community-hospitals
Khalik, S. (2016a). Community hospitals to play bigger role in patient care in the future: Gan Kim Yong. Strait Times. Retrieved from https://www. straitstimes.com/singapore/health/community-hospitals-to-play-bigger-role-in-patient-care-in-the-future-gan-kim-yong
Khalik, S. (2016b). Policyholders with riders run up higher treatment bills. Strait Times. Retrieved from https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/policyholders -with-riders-run-up-higher-treatment-bills
Khalik, S. (2017). Two quick ﬁxes to rein in healthcare costs. Strait Times. Retrieved from https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/two-quick-fixes-to-rein-in–health care-costs
Khalik, S. (2018). Healthcare Services Bill to have far broader scope and more teeth. Strait Times. Retrieved from https://www.straitstimes.com /singapore/health /new-healthcare-services-bill-to-have-far-broader-scope-and-more-teeth
Kim, S., Lee, J., & Jung, J. (2013). Assessment of medical tourism development in Korea for the achievement of competitive advantages. Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research, 18(5), 421-445.
Kohli, A. (2004). State-directed development: political power and industrialization in the global periphery. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press.
Lai, L. (2018). Committee set up to recommend medical fee benchmarks. Strait Times. Retrieved from https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/ committee–set -up-to-recommend-medical-fee-benchmarks
Lee, C. G. (2010), Health care and tourism: Evidence from Singapore. Tourism Management, 31(4), 486-488.
Lee, C. G. & Hung, W. T. (2010). Tourism, health and income in Singapore. International Journal of Tourism Research, 12(4), 355-359.
Leftwich, A. (2008). Developmental states, effective states, and poverty reduction: the primacy of politics. United Nations Research Institute for Social Development, Geneva, Switzerland.
Lim, J. (2015). Why Singapore must have foreign patients. Straits Times. Retrieved from https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/why-singapore-must -have-foreign -patients
Lim, S. (2018a). By allowing medical tourism to flourish while citizens deprived of healthcare, is irresponsibility by govt at the highest level. The Online Citizen. Retrieved from https://www.theonlinecitizen.com/2018 /09/30/while-sg-public -hospitals-take-in-foreign-patients-from-overseas-our-own-are-housed-in-tents/
Lim, J. (2018b, September 30). MOH puts a stop to foreign patient referral contracts. Strait Times. Retrieved from https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore /health/moh-puts-a-stop-to-foreign-patient-referral-contracts
Lim, C. (n.d.). Nurturing Healthcare Industry. Retrieved from https://work singapore.com/articles/industry_4.php
Liu, I. C. (2012). The research of medical tourism policy network in Taiwan. Sociology Mind, 2(4), 458–464.
Marketscreener. (2018). Thomson Medical Group (ROWS). Retrieved from https://www.marketscreener.com/THOMSON-MEDICAL-GROUP-LTD -6811873/company/
McLean, T. (2009). The Global Market for Health Care: Economics and Regulation. Wisconsin International Law Journal 26(3), 591-645.
Medhekar, A. (2010). Growth of Medical Tourism in India and Public-Private Partnerships. Paper in the proceedings of the Seventh IIDS, International Conference on Development, pp. 1-20, Calcutta 13-19 December.
Medhekar, A. (2014). Government Policy Initiatives for Developing Sustainable Medical Tourism Industry. GSTF Journal on Business Review, 3(3), 95-105.Ministry of Health Singapore. (2010). Medisave for approved Overseas Hospitalization. Press Release. Retrieved from https://www.moh.gov.sg/news -highlights/details/medisave-for-approved-overseas-hospitalisation
Ministry of Health Singapore. (2017). Handbook for Patients. Retrieved from https://www.moh.gov.sg/docs/librariesprovider5/resources-statistics/educational-resources/handbook-on-ch-care-for-patients_210617.pdf
Ministry of Health Singapore (2018a). About Health Services Act (HCSA). Retrieved from https://www.moh.gov.sg/hcsa/about-hcsa
Ministry of Health Singapore (2018b). Community Health Assistance Scheme. Retrieved from https://www.moh.gov.sg/cost-financing/healthcare–schemes -subsidies/community-health-assist-scheme
Ministry of Health Singapore (2018c). MEDIFUND. Retrieved from https://www.moh.gov.sg/cost-financing/healthcare-schemes-subsidies/medifund
Ministry of Health Singapore (2018d). MediShiled Life. Retrieved from https://www.moh.gov.sg/cost-financing/healthcare-schemes-subsidies/medishield-life
Ministry of Health Singapore. (2019a). Fee Benchmarks and Bill Amount Information: Hip, total Hip Replacement. Retrieved from
Ministry of Health Singapore. (2019b). Fee Benchmarks and Bill Amount Information: Heart, Bypass (Conventional Surgery). Retrieved from https://www.moh.gov.sg/cost-financing/fee-benchmarks-and-bill-amount-information/Details/SD812H--1
Department of Statistics Singapore. (2017). Yearbook of Statistics 2017. Retrieved from https://www.singstat.gov.sg/-/media/files/publications/reference/yearbook_2017/yos2017.pdf
MOH Holdings (2018). What we do. Retrieved from https://www. Mohh.com.sg/about-us/what-we-doNgiam,
Nikkei Asian Review. (2018a). IHH Healthcare Bhd. Retrieved from https://asia. nikkei.com/Companies/IHH-Healthcare-Bhd
Nikkei Asian Review. (2018b). Raffles Medical Group Ltd. Retrieved from https://asia.nikkei.com/Companies/Raffles-Medical-Group-Ltd
Ormond, M. (2011). Shifting subjects of healthcare: Placing “medical tourism in the context of Malaysian domestic healthcare reform. Asia Pacific Viewpoint, 52(3), 247-259.
Parkway Holdings Limited. (2018). Singapore: Our Hospitals. Retrieved from https://www.parkwaypantai.com/index-12.html
Parkway Hospital Singapore. (2019). About Us. Retrieved from https://www.parkway hospitals.com/about-us
Parkway Pantai. (2019). Hospitals. Retrieved from https://www.parkway pantai.com/hospitals/singapore
Pocock, N. S. & Phua, K. H. (2011). Medical tourism and policy implications for health systems: a conceptual framework from a comparative study of Thailand, Singapore and Malaysia. Globalization and Health, 7(1), 1-12.
Phua, K. H. (1991). Privatization and restructuring of health services in Singapore. Institute of Policy Studies (IPS), Occasional Paper No. 5, Singapore.
Phua, K. H., & Pocock, N. S. (2011). Transforming the ASEAN Economic Community (AEC) into a Global Services Hub: Enhancing the competitiveness of the health services sector in Singapore, eds. By Tereso, Jr. S. T. and Lim, H. H. in Developing Asean Economic Community (AEC) into a Global Services Hub. ERIA Research Project Report 2011, No. 1, 111-146. Economic Research Institute for ASEAN and East Asia (ERIA), Jakarta, Indonesia.
PR Newswire. (2017, August 1). Singapore Medical Tourism Market and Forecast To 2022. Press Release. Retrieved from https://www.prnewswire.com/ news-releases/singapore-medical-tourism-market-and-forecast-to-2022-300497721.html
Private Hospitals and Medical Clinics Act (PHMCA). (1999). The Government of the Republic of Singapore. Retrieved from https://sso.agc.gov.sg/Act/PHMCA1980
Raffles Medical Group. (2017). Raffles Medical Group. Retrieved from https://www.rafflesmedicalgroup.com/
Raffles Medical Group. (2018a, October 28). International Patient Services. Retrieved from https://www.rafflesmedicalgroup.com/international-patients/overview
Raffles Medical Group. (2018b, October 28). Shareholder Information. Retrieved from https://www.rafflesmedicalgroup.com/investor-relations/shareholder-information
Raffles Medical Group. (2018c). Our Heritage. Retrieved from https://www.rafflesmedicalgroup.com/raffles-medical-group/our-group/about-us/our-heritage
Raffles Medical Group. (2018d). Raffles Medical Group & Mayo Clinic - Working together for you. Retrieved from https://www.rafflesmedical group.com/raffles-medical-group/our-group/about-us/collaboration
Reuters. (2017, June 26). Global Medical Tourism Market Size, Share, Trends and Forecast by 2021 – Market Research Report 2017. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/brandfeatures/venture-capital/article?id=11869
Singapore Medical Council. (2017). Annual Report 2017. Retrieved from https://www.healthprofessionals.gov.sg/docs/librariesprovider2/publications-newsroom/smc-annual-reports/annual-report-2017.pdf
Singapore Medical Council. (2018a). Conditional Registration. Retrieved from https://www.healthprofessionals.gov.sg/smc/becoming-a-registered-doctor/register-of-medical-practitioners/conditional-registration
Singapore Medical Council. (2018b). Documentation Requirements & Processing Time. Retrieved from https://www.healthprofessionals.gov.sg/smc/becoming -a-registered-doctor/documentation-requirements-processing-time
Startup SG Network. (2019). Incentivizing Investors. Retrieved from https://ssg.startupsg.net/startupsg-investor/
Statistica. (2019). Cost of a hip replacement in selected countries as of 2018 (in U.S. dollars). Retrieved from https://www.statista.com/statistics/450373/cost-of-a-hip -replacement-in-various-countries/
Supreme Court Singapore. (2018). Singapore Judicial System. Retrieved from https://www.supremecourt.gov.sg/about-us/the-supreme-court/singapore-judicial-system
Sydney Morning Herald. (2012). Global remedy to a local affliction. Retrieved from https://www.smh.com.au/healthcare/global-remedy-to-a-local-affliction -20120505-1y5ut.html
T. D. (2013). Developing Singapore as an International Medical Centre. SMA Lecture. Retrieved from https://www.smj.org.sg/sites/default/files/5411/5411lec1.pdf
Thompson Medical Group. (2020). Our services. Retrieved from https://www. thomsonmedical.com/our-services/
United Nations Economic and Social Cooperation of the Asia-Pacific. (UNESCAP). (2009). Medical travel in Asia and the Pacific: Challenges and opportunities. Bangkok, Thailand.
Varman, R. & Manohar Vikas, R. (2007). Rising Markets and Failing Health: An Inquiry into Subaltern Health Care Consumption Under Neoliberalism, Journal of Macromarketing, 27(2), 162-172.
Waldby, C. (2009). Singapore Biopolis: Bare life in the city-state. East Asian Science, Technology and Society, 3(2-3), 367-383.
Wong, K. M. and Musa, G. (2012) Medical Tourism in Asia: Thailand, Singapore, Malaysia, and India. Retrieved from https://www.Research gate.net/profile/Brian_Wong_Kee_Mun/publication/259486257_Medical_Tourism_in_Asia_Thailand_Singapore_Malaysia_and_India/links/5487aac80cf2ef34478ecceb/Medical-Tourism-in-Asia-Thailand-Singapore-Malaysia-and-India.pdf
Woo-Cumings, M. (Ed.). (1999). The developmental state. Cornell University Press.
World Bank (2018). Current health expenditure per capita (current US$). Retrieved from https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.CHEX.PC.CD?year_high _desc=true
Yong, L. C. (2018). Internationalising Singapore Medicine. Singapore Medical Journal, 59(1), 5-8.