A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF SEO ARTICLE EFFECTIVENESS BETWEEN HUMAN AND AI WRITERS (CHATGPT, GEMINI, CLAUDE): THE CASE STUDY OF ACCOUNTING WEBSITE

Main Article Content

Supreeya Koeylao
Patama Satawedin

Abstract

In the era where Artificial Intelligence (AI) is widely used to generate digital content, AI-assisted Search Engine Optimization (SEO) writing helps save time and reduce costs but still raises concerns about content quality, language naturalness, and search performance. Therefore, comparing the effectiveness of AI writers and humans writers is essential.


The objectives of this research are 1) to study and compare the effectiveness of SEO article writing between human writers and AI writers and 2) to examine and compare the effectiveness of different AI platforms, namely ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude. Eight SEO articles were analyzed, including two human-written and six generated by AI Writers, using tax-related keywords with high search trends between January and April 2025. The evaluation was based on data obtained from Google Analytics and Google Search Console, focusing on page views, engagement rate, average engagement time per session, clicks, impressions, click-through rate, average ranking position, top search queries, and high search volumes.


The findings revealed that human-written articles achieved significantly higher page views and engagement rates and were generally ranked on the first page of search results. In contrast, articles generated by AI writers showed lower average rankings. Among the AI platforms, Gemini demonstrated the best overall performance, generating high traffic and engagement despite not appearing on the first page of search results. ChatGPT exhibited strengths in SEO-oriented content structure but required further human refinement, while Claude was found less suitable for producing business-oriented articles. In conclusion, effective SEO content creation should integrate human expertise with AI capabilities to enhance content quality and improve digital marketing performance.

Article Details

How to Cite
Koeylao, S., & Satawedin, P. (2026). A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF SEO ARTICLE EFFECTIVENESS BETWEEN HUMAN AND AI WRITERS (CHATGPT, GEMINI, CLAUDE): THE CASE STUDY OF ACCOUNTING WEBSITE. Panyapiwat Journal, 18(2), 232–242. Retrieved from https://so05.tci-thaijo.org/index.php/pimjournal/article/view/283109
Section
Research Article

References

BaHammam, A. S., Trabelsi, K., Pandi-Perumal, S. R., & Jahrami, H. (2023). Adapting to the impact of AI in scientific writing: Balancing benefits and drawbacks while developing policies and regulations. Journal of Nature and Science of Medicine, 6(3), 1-21. https://doi.org/10.4103/jnsm.jnsm_89_23

Content Shifu. (n.d.). What is a search engine? Steps and how it works. https://contentshifu.com/blog/how-search-engines-work [in Thai]

Digital Marketing Institute. (2024). What is SEO and why is it important? https://digitalmarketinginstitute.com/blog/what-is-seo-and-why-is-it-important

Fontenelle-Tereshchuk, D. (2024). Academic writing and ChatGPT: Students transitioning into college in the shadow of the COVID-19 pandemic. Discover Education, 3(6), 1-10.

Fubel, E., Groll, N. M., Gundlach, P., Han, Q., & Kaiser, M. (2023). Beyond rankings: Exploring the impact of serp features on organic click-through rates. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.01785

IDM Council. (n.d.). Which chatbot should you choose? Create prompts and analyze strengths and weaknesses of ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude. https://www.idmcouncil.com/blog/chatgpt-gemini-claude [in Thai]

Jones, P. (2024). 34 eye-opening Google search statistics for 2025. Semrush. https://www.semrush.com/blog/google-search-statistics

Maheshwari, R. K., & Sharma, S. (2024). The role of Artificial Intelligence in SEO: Enhancing search visibility and user experience. International Journal of Novel Research and Development, 9(5), a83-a86.

Miller, M. (2016). SEO and the zero moment of truth. Search Engine Land. https://searchengineland.com/seo-zero-moment-truth-242692

Nguyen, L. (2020). Building an SEO plan for a content-based business [Unpublished bachelor’s thesis]. Oulu University of Applied Sciences.

Nukulsomprattana, P. (2022). Factors affecting SEO ranking on Google. Popticles.com. https://www.popticles.com/marketing/seo-ranking-factors [in Thai]

Patel, N. (2021). How user behavior affects SEO. Neil Patel. https://neilpatel.com/blog/the-advanced-guide-to-user-behavior-data-and-how-it-affects-search-rankings

Patel, N. (2024a). AI vs human: Who writes better blogs that get more traffic? Neil Patel. https://neilpatel.com/blog/ai-vs-human-content

Patel, N. (2024b). Long-tail keywords: How-to, strategies, tips & more. Neil Patel. https://neilpatel.com/blog/how-to-integrate-long-tail-keywords-in-your-blog-posts

Phonvisutsak, S. (2023, June 9). Human vs. AI: Which SEO articles perform better? [VDO]. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KU7rKNz2Svk [in Thai]

Ravikkumar, G. (2024). AI vs. human content: Which is better for SEO & traffic? GravityWrite. https://gravitywrite.com/blog/ai-vs-human-content-the-role-of-ai-in-content-creation

Selvia, S. (2023). SEO Article Writing Experiment: AI vs Human. cmlabs. https://cmlabs.co/en-id/blog/seo-content-experiment-ai-vs-human

Sissons, O. (2023). AI vs. humans: Content writing SEO experiment. Reboot Online. https://www.rebootonline.com/blog/ai-vs-humans-content-writing-seo-experiment

Sukko, S. (2021). Boosting your website to be No.1 in customers’ minds with SEO (3rd ed.). IDC Publishing. [in Thai]

Tiyaporn, W. (2021). Effective SEO content strategy: The case study of coffee product website titled “Baristabuddy.co.th” under Barista Buddy Co., Ltd. [Independent study]. Bangkok University. [in Thai]

Valchanov, I. (2024). 35 best ChatGPT prompts for SEO in 2024. Juma. https://team-gpt.com/blog/chatgpt-prompts-for-seo

Whitbeck, C. (2024). 11 must-try ChatGPT prompts for SEO content writing. Team-GPT. https://www.brafton.com/blog/ai/chatgpt-prompts-for-seo-content-writing